A short-term funding patch would open some closed gates and put conservation workers back on the job, but there could be long-term consequences for public and private lands
News outlets are reporting that lawmakers have reached a deal to reopen the nine federal departments that have been shut down for more than a month. The temporary funding extension would buy Congress three weeks to come to a long-term agreement.
Over the past few weeks, sportsmen and women have been posting to social media and speaking with reporters about how this historic shutdown has affected hunting and fishing opportunities across the country. During this time, the Bureau of Land Management, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture, and U.S. Forest Service—some of the nation’s most important land management agencies—have been without funding.
Here are some of the access challenges, risks to public lands, and delayed conservation work that made news during the shutdown.
Whoops, forgot Flourissant is an National Landmark and therefore part of the #GovernmentShutdown pic.twitter.com/HgQKWj2yEB
— APT Outdoors (@APTOutdoors) January 19, 2019
Locked Out, Left Home
While some national wildlife refuge employees returned to work to prevent lost hunting opportunities, an estimated 800,000 federal workers were furloughed without pay—this included public-lands firefighters, wildlife biologists, law-enforcement officers, foresters, and maintenance workers.
Understaffing may have contributed to some of the reports we saw of hunters and anglers locked out of public lands. In Idaho, volunteers picked up trash around a popular fishing area within Deer Flat Wildlife Refuge, but the shutdown delayed the repair of an access gate that was damaged on Jan. 1 in a vehicle crash. Normally, the timer-operated gate closes automatically at 5:30 p.m. to discourage vandalism after hours. For now, it remains stuck closed.
Stunted Growth
Just days before the shutdown, President Trump signed into law a new five-year farm bill, which—despite being nearly two months behind schedule—included some big wins for habitat and public access. Farmers and ranchers had already experienced months of uncertainty while the farm bill debate stretched into overtime, and the shutdown delayed farm bill benefits even further. Politico reports that some farmers may not be able to take advantage of other USDA programs in time for the growing season, either.
Failure to Launch
In mid-December, the EPA and the Army Corps took the next step to replace a 2015 rule that benefited headwater streams and wetlands across the country. We know from a 2018 poll that 4 in 5 sportsmen and women supported this move, but the agencies’ new rule would instead roll back these Clean Water Act protections. Because of the shutdown, however, hunters and anglers have been prevented from voicing their feedback on the new rule, keeping waterfowl and fish habitat in limbo.
Waiting for Numbers
Another unintended consequence of the government shutdown might be delayed research that could help sportsmen and women advocate for better policies. For example, it is likely that some marine fisheries stock assessments will be postponed. And this could influence decision-making if the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission meets to consider important management questions without the latest striped bass stock assessment—which is likely to show that the population is overfished.
Funding Shortfalls Stack Up
Unfortunately, the shutdown is also adding to the growing $18.6 billion maintenance backlog on our public lands. The bulk of that figure is tied to overdue projects in national parks, but more than $7 billion in deferred maintenance work is affecting BLM, Forest Service, and national refuge lands where we hunt and fish.
Quite simply, even if Congress can strike a long-term bargain before this deal expires on Feb. 15, it may take years to make up for the time and funding lost during this shutdown.
Top photo by seth schulte on Unsplash
When Representatives can’t perform their Legislative assignments, There should be a Law stating that they cannot shutdown the Government because they failed to achieve, that’s an under successful performance. And, causing Public Federal Land Agencies, to lock the gates must be stopped!
Pont of clarification: It was the President who caused the shutdown. Althogh Sen. McConnell could have at least reintroduced the CR that had previously been passd 100-0. But, no. And I would have much prefered the public lands, parks, etc. ALL be loked during the shutdown as opposed to being given over to poachers, vandals & thieves.
What can I do to help gain access to private hunting lands?
Good question, Bryan. We’re gathering information on the state walk-in access programs that are funded through the Farm Bill. Where do you hunt?
There is no mechanism in place for the President and Congress to have ownership of their lack of ability to do their jobs. There should never be a day that the government shuts down because of politics. The Senate Majority Leader should not be allowed to refuse to take bills to the President because he doesn’t want to suffer the Presidents wrath. If he doesn’t have the moxie to do his job then remove him from office. It is high time that Congress starts doing its job and representing the people that elected them.
The amount of damage done to our parks and land will take months to repair. The damage to the national monuments can never be repaired. I FISH, I HUNT, and I HIKE and I VOTE!!!